Fourth Sunday in the Midst of Lent (Year C)
Text: Luke 15:1-3, 11b-32
Now all the tax-collectors and sinners were coming near to listen to [Jesus]. And the Pharisees and the scribes were grumbling and saying, ‘This fellow welcomes sinners and eats with them.’ So he told them this parable … ‘There was a man who had two sons. The younger of them said to his father, “Father, give me the share of the property that will belong to me …”
The parable of the “prodigal” (or “lost”) son has a dual message, both sides of which have implications for the church today.
The most obvious—and most widely embraced—dimension of the message is God’s unconditional acceptance of anyone who turns to God.
We encounter this dimension of the message when we approach the parable from the perspective of the prodigal son.
For his own reasons, this young man makes the decision to leave his family and seek to build a new life for himself elsewhere. The story gives the impression that the separation is not amicable. Nevertheless, his father gives him his share of the inheritance—and then the boy is on his way.
The son has no intention of returning. He is confident that his inheritance will be enough to get him established away from home. He believes that he now has the means to lead his life as he pleases.
As it turns out, he wastes his resources and soon finds himself destitute.
The logical thing to do under these circumstances would be to return home, acknowledge his mistake, and perhaps apologize to his parents.
But would his family take him back? Would they forgive him?
Had the separation been frictionless, there would have been no reason to doubt his acceptance back into the family. He would have wasted no time in returning.
However—whether out of pride or fear—he resists going home, until his situation deteriorates to a point where he simply has no choice but to seek his family’s forgiveness. So he swallows hard and makes his way back.
The point of the story from this perspective is the enthusiasm with which the father receives his son. He hurries down the road to meet him. He does not scold him for having made a bad decision in the past. Neither does the father humiliate his son by telling him, “I told you so.” The past is gone and forgotten. Their relationship begins on a new page with great potential.
Jesus says that God’s love for each one of us is just like that. Like a parent who accepts and receives the wayward child without question. Never fear that you may have gone too far beyond God’s grace. You will always be part of the family. The door is always wide open for you. This truly is good news for all of us who—for one reason or another—feel unworthy.
However, there is another dimension to this parable—and to the ones which precede it (see verses 4-10). It’s a dimension which is usually ignored, but it’s arguably the most important one, because it reveals the purpose of Jesus’ teaching here. Remember that his immediate audience is made up of those Pharisees and scribes who grumble about his association with “sinners.”
Behind the three parables in chapter 15 of Luke—the “lost sheep”, the “lost coin” and the “lost son”—is a not-so-veiled message for those who believe themselves to be more righteous than most; those at the centre of the established order, the custodians of the prevailing norms and values.
Jesus has noticed how these self-proclaimed gate-keepers abuse their power, how they deny people free access to God’s blessings, how they impose upon the people burdensome and unjust rules. In parable after parable, he warns that there will be a huge surprise when “sinners” and outcasts enter the kingdom ahead of the good and respectable people.
Sinners and outcasts will be accepted because of their genuine contrition and the simplicity of their faith.
One interesting—though often ignored—character in today’s parable is the elder brother. He has all the external characteristics of the “good son.” He works hard and remains faithful to his parents. He does not fight with them. He does not ask for his inheritance prematurely like his brother did. He is a good son.
But the story takes an interesting twist at the end when we discover that while the brother is good on the outside, he is rotten on the inside. He’s bitter. He’s jealous. In fact, we discover that his motives were never entirely pure.
“For all these years,” he says, “I have been working like a slave for you, and I have never disobeyed your command; yet you have never given me even a young goat so that I might celebrate with my friends.” (v. 29)
Jesus is making a subtle but definite critique against those who dare to consider themselves more deserving than others. He says that it is not enough to show obedience outwardly if there is no love and compassion in one’s heart.
Indeed, the person in our midst who may outwardly appear to be unworthy—but whose heart is genuinely set toward God—will be accepted by God ahead of us.
Way too often—even in our present day—we seek to exclude those whom we see as “not like us”. We may do this on such grounds as morality or status or “family values”, or simply because—in our judgment—they somehow do not measure up. It’s like ridiculing someone for failing to wear a suit and tie (whether to church or to the Oval Office).
This attitude of exclusion is sad enough when it runs rampant in the church. However, it is downright dangerous when it bleeds into the larger society, as it appears to be doing in many western societies—perhaps most glaringly in the United States of America, where Donald Trump’s approach to immigration has drastically escalated arrests and deportations of women, children and men.
According to some estimates, the U.S.A. may be home to as many as 14 million persons without legal status. Trump has said that he wants to deport all of them—and, indeed, arrests by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) spiked to as many as 1,200 per day during his first week in office.
Data published in late February showed ICE had nearly 44,000 immigrants in detention. Since this exceeded the agency’s funding and capacity, the Trump administration swiftly struck or expanded agreements with Mexico, Guatemala, El Salvador, Panama, and Costa Rica to take the deportees. Notably, the deportations to Panama have raised concerns about treatment of the migrants, including that of more than 100 sent to a camp near the Darien Gap jungle. To speed the process up, Trump has ordered his armed forces to assist with deportation operations, leading to military deportation flights to Guatemala, Honduras, Panama, Ecuador, Peru and India.
The president has also targeted legal immigration, attempting to freeze the U.S. refugee resettlement program and revoke visas and green cards of students who’ve participated in pro-Palestinian protests. Trump has even tried to restrict automatic birthright citizenship by means of executive order.
Beatriz Lopez, co-executive director of the Immigration Hub, a Washington-based advocacy organization, has lamented the disruption and destabilization of families and communities, saying, “This is clearly them going after people who aren’t criminals, who don’t fit their version of America.”1
Alas, all this mayhem is apparently condoned—and even applauded—by literally millions of American Christians who voted for Donald Trump in 20242, and who continue offering their vocal support to his inhumane policies.
For those labelled as outsiders, every effort is made to keep them excluded. How horrible that any of this is being done in the name of Jesus.
Let’s be clear: this is not what Jesus was about! This is not the Jesus we see in Scripture, who dined with sinners and tax collectors; the Jesus who had compassion for the very people society rejected.
Jesus’ teaching should cause all of us to pause and think. For those among us who are inclined to be like the prodigal son, he extends God’s grace and reminds us that God will never give up on us. God accepts us unconditionally. No one gets deported from the Kingdom of Heaven. We are welcomed in the same way the prodigal son was welcomed.
For those among us who are inclined to be like the disgruntled brother, Jesus says outward obedience is not enough. We need to have compassion and love for our neighbour, and to be accepting of all people.
May the Spirit of God touch our hearts, and bring us the message of compassion and inclusion we so desperately need to hear. For Jesus’ sake. Amen.
_________________________
1 https://www.aol.com/news/trumps-immigration-policies-support-expands-195534961.html
2 According to exit polls, 72% of white Christians voted for Trump in 2024. https://www.prri.org/spotlight/religion-and-the-2024-presidential-election/
