A SERMON FOR WORLD COMMUNION SUNDAY
TEXT: Acts 5:27-42
“If this plan or this undertaking is of human origin, it will fail; but if it is of God, you will not be able to overthrow them …” (Acts 5:38b-39a)
World Communion Sunday reminds us of our global connections. It makes us think about our ties to Christians across the earth—and about the value of generosity toward others. Those are worthwhile things to consider on this day—especially given the fact that church history records more discord than harmony between Christians.
Most of that strife has been, frankly, born of narrow-mindedness, intolerance, and the conviction of all parties involved that their particular group, or sect, or denomination has a monopoly on the truth. And we so-called “liberal” Christians are as guilty of this as are the fundamentalists.
Now, when you’re absolutely convinced that your way is the right way—and if you believe that defence of the revealed truth is your responsibility … Well, let’s just say that few things can get people as worked up as can religion. Our passage from the Book of Acts demonstrates that this has been true for a very long time.
The early church was having a tough go of it. Having been energized by the universal Spirit on Pentecost, they were preaching a controversial Christian message everywhere anyone would listen. Now, you have to remember that Christian faith is a product of Judaism, and almost all of the earliest followers of Jesus were Jews. They did not intend to start a new religion, but they did believe that God had given them a new—and quite radically different—way of thinking about their Jewish faith.
The Jewish religious authorities, however, were not impressed. They had the disciples arrested and brought before the council. It looked like the entire leadership of the early church would not leave that place alive.
In the midst of this explosive atmosphere, a big-spirited rabbi named Gamaliel stood up to offer some wise counsel about tolerance. He said:
“Fellow Israelites, consider carefully what you propose to do to these men … In this case it might be best to leave them be; because if this undertaking is of human origin, it will fail. But if it is of God, you will not be able to stop it—you might even be fighting against God!”
Fortunately for the Apostles, Gamaliel was a person of no small influence. A prominent Pharisee, he was a highly-respected scholar and teacher, and had been a pupil of the esteemed Hillel. The council took Gamaliel’s advice and let the apostles go.
Gamaliel was a voice of moderation in an age that was every bit as intolerant as our own. His instincts were inclusive and progressive. He favoured modification of some of the stricter Sabbath laws, and championed the rights of women. Quite an interesting figure.
You know, there are two kinds of tolerance. One kind is a permissive attitude that says, “Anything goes. Nothing matters. Live and let live.” It’s easy to be tolerant when you don’t believe in anything!
But that was not Gamaliel. His was a tolerance of conviction. He was loyal to Israel’s covenant. He believed in God. In fact, his attitude toward the disciples was rooted in his belief about God. “Don’t worry; if this is a human venture, it will fail.” On the other hand, “If God is behind it, there is nothing you can do to stop it.” And then this little zinger: “In fact, you would be opposing God!”
This really is a pivotal point in the church’s story. It was a situation where all the apostles could have been put to death at once, and there might be no Christianity today—if not for Gamaliel. It’s no wonder, then, that he was a beloved figure to Christians. And it’s no wonder that the church has never forgotten him.
But then, God always seems to have some Gamaliel type around to preserve his cause: people who have a universal outlook, who are compassionate, and caring, and cut others some slack. I think this story from the Book of Acts has a lot to teach us about causes that appear to be lost but which—in the end—win. And I think it has something to say also about causes that look very promising at first, but end up losing.
When two men came after dark to bury Jesus’ body, it looked for all practical purposes that they had bet on a lost cause. But that all changed on Easter morning!
When Rosa Parks refused to give her seat to a person just because he was white, she appeared so outnumbered. What could possibly come from such an insignificant event in Montgomery, Alabama? How could she ever hope to win? Yet her courageous act of protest marked a turning point for the American civil rights movement. It didn’t look like much at the time, but when Rosa Parks sat down, the world sat up and took notice! The universal spirit prevailed, and the better side of the American conscience made necessary changes to end discrimination because of a person’s colour or gender.
Conversely, some movements appear destined to win. Adolf Hitler’s Germany was a seemingly unbeatable power in the early 1940s. With overwhelming military might and an agenda intent on conquering the world, it looked for a while as if it would happen. European Jewry had been decimated. Russia had its back to the wall. England was hanging by a thread. Canada and America were going to be next.
But God had Dietrich Bonhoeffer. And God had Harry Truman, and Winston Churchill, and Dwight Eisenhower. God had the Canadian Third Division at Juno Beach. And in the end, the racist claims and hateful actions of the Nazis came to nothing.
Things come and go. Gamaliel was wise enough to know that. And he had faith enough to know this: those things that are of God will last! And those things that are not of God … well, they won’t make it.
Be patient. Wait and see. Things are not always what they appear to be. You have to “winter and summer” with some movements before you understand what they’re really like. There are always things about which people were very sure once-upon-a-time, that they aren’t so sure about anymore. Sometimes what people once thought was the will of God, later seems to clearly not have been from God at all.
Throughout history God has worked in ways none of us understand. To his everlasting credit, Gamaliel seemed to recognize that, which is why he advised: “Be careful here. God may be at work!”
That’s why some things that are clear now are the opposite of things that were clear to people of yesterday. Sometimes it pays to be a little tentative and wait for God to act—to wait for a clearer picture, for more time, for more events to happen—so we can see in which direction God is leading us.
In any event, when we buy that kind of time, we allow ourselves to reserve judgment about certain things—and certain people. And we Christians are a diverse group, you know. Just within my own denomination, we have religious liberals and religious conservatives; we have feminists and we have traditionalists. We have young and old, male and female, people who love the old hymns and people who want to experiment with new music and new forms of worship. If we had a motto, it might be this: “We reserve the right to accept everybody.”
Every day, I see people displaying that kind of acceptance—probably without even realizing they’re doing it. Does it make a difference? You bet it does! To be open to others; to welcome the stranger; to focus on people’s strengths, and not their weaknesses—these are radical acts of tolerance and compassion in a too-often cruel and intolerant world.
It fell to Peter to be the leader of the early Christian movement, but he could not have done it without Gamaliel’s universal spirit.
So, on this World Communion Sunday, I think we should celebrate the ministry of Rabbi Gamaliel. Because today we are reminded that Christ has called us to a table that is universal, that encompasses all the diversities of this world—a table where all are welcome, where human differences are recognized as gifts, not as burdens.
We may not know everything, but we do know some things. We know who God is and where God may be found. And we know how to share the love that is in our hearts. And make no mistake about it: there is a lot of love to share. Soon, it will be time to gather around the table of our Lord. In the spirit of Gamaliel, I invite you. Amen.