Third Sunday in the Midst of Lent (Year C)
TEXT: Luke 13:1-9
[Jesus] asked them, “Do you think that because these Galileans suffered in this way they were worse sinners than all other Galileans? … Or those eighteen who were killed when the tower of Siloam fell on them—do you think that they were worse offenders than all the others living in Jerusalem?” (Luke 13:2, 4)
On a website called “Day One,” Joe Evans tells the following story:
About two years ago I was with a group on a mission trip to Haiti, and we were flying from one side of the island to another in a little propeller plane driven by a Cuban pilot.
The turbulence was horrible and once we landed we were all thankful to finally be on solid ground again. While unloading the baggage, one member of the group says to another, “I wasn’t worried. Our pastor was head bowed in prayer the whole flight.”
And I’m glad that when she saw me with my head bowed on that turbulent flight that’s what she thought I was doing—because in reality I was putting my head down because I thought that would keep me from throwing up. 1
Pastor Evans makes this observation: “You have to be careful with people,” he says, “because if they don’t know the answer, they may well just make something up.”
Turn on the television news—or pick up a newspaper—on any given day, and you will find a report about some catastrophic tragedy happening somewhere. Only the locations change.
Tornadoes, floods, earthquakes, tsunamis, shootings, bombings, acts of war—all of them happening, it seems, all of the time. All of them wreaking havoc. All of them breaking hearts and leaving permanent scars.
And behind them—usually left unreported—are the larger tragedies, like the nine million people who die every year of hunger or hunger-related causes. When you do the math, that amounts to approximately one death every five seconds, and—sadly—it’s children who die most often.2
For every one of those deaths, families or loved ones grieved—for every single one. And at some level, every one of those grieving souls probably asked the same question: “Why?”
It just doesn’t seem fair. What had any of those folks done to deserve such tragic deaths?
In Jesus’ day, there was no question about fairness. The assumption was that disease, suffering, and death bore a direct correlation with human sinfulness: the greater the sin, the worse the misfortune.
There was a group of Galileans “whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices.” For whatever reason, the Roman governor saw these individuals as a problem, and so he dispatched soldiers to kill them—apparently either on their way to the Jerusalem Temple, or perhaps even in the Temple itself.
And then there were the 18 who died when the tower in Siloam fell.
When confronted with such terrible events, we want an answer to the question of “Why?” And whether the answer is true or not … Well, that may not even matter so much, because having an answer—any answer—feels much better than not knowing.
Some years back, Forbes magazine published an article by Holly Green entitled: “Ten Good Reasons Not to Trust Your Brain.” I won’t repeat all 10 of the reasons she gives, but here are a few:
First of all, your brain jumps to conclusions; it sees what it wants to see. Not only that, but:
-
- it twists and distorts incoming information so that it aligns with your own assumptions;
- it has too much confidence in its own abilities; and
- it constantly makes stuff up!
As Holly Green put it: “In the absence of information, we make stuff up. We do it all the time, and then we believe it to be true! Our brain won’t live with a void, so it fills in the blanks.” 3
We want to know, “Why do bad things happen?”
Why did Pilate have those worshippers killed?
Why did that tower fall on those particular eighteen people?
And how can I prevent the same thing from happening to me and the people I love?
Almost any answer to these questions will do—just so long as there is some kind of an answer. And the more an answer allows me to believe that the same thing won’t happen to me … Well, the more I like that answer.
When it came to explaining the murder of those Galileans and the sudden death of the eighteen, a popular answer was that of “retribution for sin.”
In other words, bad things happen to bad people. Suffering is evidence of divine justice at work. People suffer because they deserve it. But as long as you keep your nose clean and mind your own business, the same fate will not befall you.
Now, on the face of it, this idea does appear biblically-sound. In the Book of Deuteronomy, we read that disobedience results in punishment—not only for the disobedient, but even for their children and grandchildren. It says:
“… I the LORD your God am a jealous God, punishing children for the iniquity of parents, to the third and fourth generation of those who reject me …” (Deut. 5:9).
However—biblical or not—Jesus is having none of it. Rather than agree with conventional wisdom, Jesus holds the crowd accountable for their own behaviour.
He asked them, “Do you think that because these Galileans suffered in this way they were worse sinners than all other Galileans? No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all perish as they did. Or those eighteen who were killed when the tower of Siloam fell on them—do you think that they were worse offenders than all the others living in Jerusalem? No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all perish just as they did” (Luke 13:2-5).
Now, that doesn’t seem very pastoral, does it? Jesus sounds less compassionate here than we might expect him to be.
Apparently, he is not so much trying to comfort these folks as he is aiming to challenge them. And because Luke has included this episode in his gospel, we can assume that it’s meant to challenge us, as well.
Jesus moves our focus away from what lies outside of our control. He warns us not to accept simple or judgmental explanations that only build up self-righteousness. Instead, Jesus calls us to focus on those things of which we are in control.
To make that point, Jesus tells a parable. It’s not exactly a warm and fuzzy parable. In fact, it emphasizes God’s judgment and underscores the need for repentance.
He tells the story of a fig tree that is not producing, and how the landowner is fed up with its apparent inability to bear fruit. He proposes cutting the tree down: “Why should it be wasting the soil?”
But the gardener argues for a one-year reprieve.
“Let me work with the tree for one more year,” he says. “And if it does not produce fruit, then we can cut it down.”
The passage concludes just like that; an ambiguous ending, if ever there was one.
As I said earlier—quoting that article from Forbes—our brains do not like ambiguity. If we don’t know the answer to something, our brains tend to just make something up!
If you think this sounds like current U.S. politics, you’re not wrong.
-
- Don’t know how to make public schools teach right-wing propaganda? Dismantle the Department of Education.
- Don’t know how to solve the opioid crisis? Focus on the less than 20 kilograms of fentanyl coming in from Canada each year.
- Don’t know how to stimulate the economy? Implement policies that will cost thousands of American workers their jobs, and cause the stock market to plummet.
Over the past few weeks, I have been offering blog posts which, I admit, are mostly aimed at my fellow Canadians. Well … Canadians, and any Americans who may disagree with their president’s stated intention to annex his northern neighbour, turning Canada into a “51st state” by first destroying its economy with crippling tariffs.
I’ve tried to point out the autocratic tendencies of Donald Trump, including some frightening parallels to a 1940s-era German dictator who has widely been considered an antichrist.
Then, after Trump unilaterally renamed the Gulf of Mexico—declaring it to be “The Gulf of America”—I suggested changing the White House street address to “666 Pennsylvania Avenue” (tongue in cheek, I assure you).
I’ve also noted his eagerness to harshly condemn Christian leaders who dare question his policies. This includes, by the way, not only the Episcopal Bishop of Washington (the Right Rev. Mariann Budde, who called him to account publicly), but also Pope Francis, who—way back in 2016—said that “A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian.”
Realizing that Donald Trump is not the only American who dreams of global domination, I’ve even appealed to divine justice, quoting a prayer first lifted up against Norse raiders who came to devastate and pillage, laying ruin to the defenceless: “Our supreme and holy Grace, protecting us and ours, deliver us, God, from the savage race which lays waste our realms.”
Am I overreacting? I don’t think so. Neither is Timmins-James Bay Member of Parliament Charlie Angus, who has branded Trump’s rhetoric and trade policies as nothing short of an “act of war.”
Faced with this kind of existential threat—and not knowing quite what to do about it—our Canadian brains may cast about wildly, trying to fill the void of our anxiety with some kind of useful response.
-
- Should we cut off electrical power to New York state? (That’ll show ’em.)
- Should we bend over like an Alberta politician, offering up a tantalizing vision of a southbound pipeline, glistening with oilsands crude? (Be gentle, Donald.)
- Should we just give up, accept 51st-statehood, and go buy assault rifles? (So we’ll fit in better)
Over these past weeks, I have not been able to ignore the fact that Canada’s position in the world is precarious, now that the United States—once our closest ally—has become, astonishingly, our most dangerous adversary.
Even so, I do not intend to preach a doomsday message today. What I want to preach about (or preach against) is temptation—especially and particularly the temptation to despair. The temptation to quit. To deny that we have a God who can and does act in our lives.
Throughout our entire 158-year history as a nation, Canadians have faced one profound challenge after another. Two world wars. The Great Depression. The October Crisis of 1970. Recession in the 1990s. The financial crisis of 2008. The COVID pandemic. And we have overcome them all by the grace of God, who has blessed us with creative thinkers and diligent workers.
To be sure, we are on the verge of a severe economic downturn, precipitated by assaults upon our sovereignty. The damage is already being felt. Every one of us, I’m sure, knows somebody who has lost their job, or is watching their business fail. And of course, the fallout from that is going to limit what people have available to give to charities of all kinds.
But now is not the time to give up on the True North, Strong and Free! I believe that, by the grace of God, we will be spared the axe which our enemies are grinding. Rest assured, we’ve been given much more than just another year. The question now is: what will we do with that future? What will we do with the Lord’s blessing?
Another question is: do we truly believe that God is able to improve our situation, if we do our part? Are we willing to do our part—even if that means doing things differently than we’ve done in the past? Are we willing to seize the day?
I trust that we are. Whatever yesterday was like—for better or for worse—we have been given the gift of today. And today, Jesus the gardener is ready to work with us and through us—nourishing us by his Spirit, nurturing and caring for us by his almighty grace, so that we might bear yet more fruit.
Throughout this season of Lent, we are being called to give thanks to the One who has spared us from the axe and given us the gift of today. Let us not squander this gift through complacency, or defeatism, or by returning to old ways that no longer work. Rather, let’s take this time to practice self-examination. Not worrying about things over which we have no control. Not criticizing one another for what has or has not been done in the past.
But rather, let us—each one of us—devote ourselves to the examination of something we actually can change: namely, our own behaviour. Our behaviour as a body of believers—and our behaviour as individuals within it.
The season of Lent is a time to focus not on who is worse or what is wrong with everybody else. No. This season of Lent is a time to focus on what could be better—with me, and with you.
In Canada, a federal election is looming. Whomever you choose to vote for, I hope you vote. Make no mistake about it: the more of you who participate in public life, the healthier and stronger and more vibrant this nation will become. Our fruit will be more abundant. And, I suspect, the sweeter it will taste.
The fig tree was spared the axe. We have been, as well. By the grace of Christ, we will survive. God has spared us, and in his mercy, he has given us the gift of today. Let’s not ignore this opportunity or take this gift for granted. Instead, let’s use this gift of time to nurture in ourselves the fruits of righteousness and love; in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ. Amen.
__________________
1 http://day1.org/4534-spared_the_ax
2 https://www.concern.org.uk/news/world-hunger-facts-figures
3 www.forbes.com/sites/work-in-progress/2012/10/23/10-good-reasons-not-to-trust-your-brain/#72d8429a2e94